11 Would possibly 2024
Gordon Corera,Safety correspondent, @gordoncorera
![BBC Yan Xiong pictured with loudspeaker at Tiananmen Square](https://i0.wp.com/ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/653b/live/f9935850-0ed9-11ef-b9d8-4f52aebe147d.jpg.webp?ssl=1)
3 many years in the past, Chinese language dissidents have been being smuggled abroad in a undercover operation referred to as Yellow Chook – however as one in every of them tells the BBC, Beijing continues to be pursuing them.
June 1992: It was once the midnight at the South China Sea, and a Chinese language patrol vessel was once drawing near a ship en path from the Communist mainland to the then-British colony of Hong Kong.
As border troops got here on board to speak to the group, their voices may well be heard by means of a bunch of crowd packed right into a undercover compartment underneath deck.
A couple of mins previous, when the patrol boat was once noticed, those undercover passengers have been given an pressing sequence.
“I was told to hide,” one in every of them, Yan Xiong, remembers. “Don’t make any noise!”
Maximum of the ones hiding have been financial migrants, hoping to search out paintings in Hong Kong – however no longer Yan.
He was once a political dissident, and if he was once found out, he could be in deep trouble.
Yan was once being smuggled out of China as a part of a undercover operation code-named Yellow Chook.
The patrol sooner or later sailed away, and within the early hours Yan – who had by no means travelled in a ship ahead of that evening – arrived in Hong Kong.
Later a hearty breakfast, he was once taken to a detention centre. This was once, he was once informed, for his personal protection. Strolling the streets may well be unhealthy.
!["listen on BBC sounds"](https://i0.wp.com/ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/6e56/live/1d285e00-0ebc-11ef-bee9-6125e244a4cd.png.webp?ssl=1)
![orange strap](https://i0.wp.com/ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/8432/live/34e77800-0ebc-11ef-b9d8-4f52aebe147d.png.webp?ssl=1)
Being in detention was once no longer untouched to Yan. He had already spent 19 months in a Chinese language jail for his section in 1989’s Tiananmen Sq. protests. Scholars had referred to as for higher autonomy and independence, however the Communist Celebration despatched in tanks to overwhelm them.
On the finish of June 1989, the Chinese language executive mentioned that 200 civilians and several other quantity safety team of workers had died. Alternative estimates have ranged from masses to many hundreds.
On his let go, Yan had made his option to southern China the place, in scenes that will have been taken from a undercover agent movie, he was once despatched from one society telephone sales space to every other, to be installed contact with the crowd who may get him out.
He was once no longer the one dissident to adopt this dangerous advance.
Chatting with the BBC for a untouched sequence, Silhoutte Battle: China and the West, Chaohua Wang remembers her retirement.
In spite of being quantity 14 on a listing of the 21 maximum sought after crowd later the Tiananmen Sq. protests, she controlled to evade seize, hiding in slight rooms for months ahead of heading south and turning into a part of the Yellow Chook retirement sequence.
“I was like a parcel moved from one [person] to another,” she says.
“I didn’t even know the name Yellow Bird for quite some years.”
Yellow Chook might tone like a vintage undercover agent operation, and lots of conceived that an perception provider – MI6 or the CIA – had get a hold of the speculation. However that they had no longer.
Actually, it was once a non-public undertaking undertaken by means of involved teams of electorate in Hong Kong, progressive by means of a want to assistance out those that have been at the run. Between them have been the native movie and leisure business and (extra usefully) organised crime, within the method of the triads.
![Reuters Chinese army tanks put down the Tiananmen Square protests](https://i0.wp.com/ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/d9fc/live/de6a7020-0ebd-11ef-82e8-cd354766a224.jpg.webp?ssl=1)
“They [the triads] had a lot of Chinese police in their pockets,” says Nigel Inkster, who at that era was once an perception officer founded in Hong Kong. This was once what enabled them to advance crowd out of hiding in Beijing and smuggle them around the border.
The United Kingdom and US most effective changed into concerned when the ones crowd who arrived in Hong Kong had to figure out the place to progress upcoming.
Yan recalls being visited by means of what he described as an “English gentleman” who by no means gave his identify however helped him with the forms.
“It is better for you to go to America, not England,” the person informed him. Inside days Yan was once in Los Angeles. Chaohua Wang additionally ended up in the United States.
Why no longer England?
Former officers have informed the BBC the United Kingdom was once resistant to absorb Tiananmen protesters as it was once determined to keep away from scary China within the run-up to the 1997 provide of Hong Kong.
An word of honour have been signed by means of the United Kingdom in 1984, however the occasions of Tiananmen Sq. 5 years next raised tough questions on Hong Kong’s past.
![Getty Images Lord Patten meets locals in Hong Kong, March 1996](https://i0.wp.com/ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/03d6/live/e51e3800-0ebf-11ef-82e8-cd354766a224.jpg.webp?ssl=1)
In 1992, a couple of weeks later Yan’s arrival within the colony, the previous Conservative cupboard minister Chris Patten changed into the closing governor of Hong Kong.
He says he was once progressive to embed higher autonomy, within the hope it could undergo later the provide, and he introduced proposals for the democratic reform of Hong Kong’s establishments, aimed toward broadening the vote casting bottom in elections.
There was once opposition to the reforms no longer simply from China’s management but in addition from the ones in London who didn’t wish to antagonise Beijing.
“My main responsibility was to try to give people in Hong Kong the best chance of continuing to live in freedom and prosperity, and to do so after 1997,” the previous governor, now Lord Patten, tells me. He says he additionally was once conscious about – however no longer excited about – Yellow Chook.
The reluctance to permit dissidents to return to the United Kingdom – and the rage in some quarters about Patten’s reforms – speaks to a central query from the Nineteen Nineties which nonetheless issues nowadays: How a ways will have to the West progress to keep away from angering China and accommodate its be on one?s feet, particularly with regards to values like human rights and autonomy?
Yellow Chook ended at the wet evening in July 1997 when Hong Kong changed into distant Chinese language dimension. For a couple of years, the liberties that Patten have been seeking to store, held. However within the while decade, China – beneath Xi Jinping – has taken a extra authoritarian flip and has attempted in order Hong Kong into sequence.
![Getty Images Chinese president Jiang Zemin shakes hand with Charles, Prince of Wales at the Hong Kong handover ceremony at HK Convention and Exhibition Centre, to mark Hong Kong's return to Chinese sovereignty at midnight, 30 June 1997.](https://i0.wp.com/ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/c3cb/live/722a01c0-0ec0-11ef-8f3e-f3c169ee7041.jpg.webp?ssl=1)
Yan took US citizenship and lived a type American date. He joined the United States military and served in Iraq as an army chaplain.
He may have concept the hand of China’s Communist Celebration may no longer succeed in him in his untouched house, however he was once incorrect.
In 2021, he made up our minds to run for society place of job. He stood as a candidate within the Democratic number one for Brandnew York’s 1st Congressional District.
Yan began noticing some bizarre occurrences throughout his marketing campaign. Unusual vehicles adopted him and lurked outdoor the place he was once staying at 3 within the morning. At marketing campaign occasions, crowd would effort to restrain him from talking.
![Yan Xiong in full US military uniform](https://i0.wp.com/ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/cc5e/live/f448bf60-0ec1-11ef-82e8-cd354766a224.jpg.webp?ssl=1)
He realized why when the FBI got here to speak to him. A US non-public investigator had informed them he have been approached by means of a person in China, who had requested him to hold out surveillance on Yan. It kind of feels the speculation of a former Tiananmen protester coming into US Congress was once unwanted.
“He had specifically told our private investigator that they needed to undermine the victim’s candidacy,” says FBI agent Jason Moritz.
The FBI have been ready to watch occasions because the Chinese language-based person proposed the investigator dig up filth on Yan. If he may no longer in finding any, he was once steered to build some up. If that didn’t paintings, beating him up and even staging a automobile clash was once advised.
“They want to smother and kill my campaign,” Yan explains.
![Campaign poster for Yan Xiong 2022](https://i0.wp.com/ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/480/cpsprodpb/e58d/live/ffed0630-0ec3-11ef-b9d8-4f52aebe147d.jpg.webp?ssl=1)
The individual educating the non-public investigator, the FBI assessed, was once running by and for China’s Ministry of Surrounding Safety. They have been indicted however may no longer be arrested as a result of they have been outdoor the United States.
China has constantly denied claims of political interference. However this isn’t the one case the place it’s speculated to have turn into extra assertive in monitoring ill the ones it considers dissidents in alternative international locations. There were claims of “overseas police stations” in the United Kingdom and US and of people being confused to go back to China or be tranquil.
Yan’s tale unearths that as China has turn into extra assured and controlling at house, it has additionally sought to increase its succeed in in a foreign country. And that’s more and more inflicting friction over problems with espionage, surveillance and human rights.
In the meantime, Yan’s message to Western governments when coping with China is discreet: “They’ve got to be careful.”
Silhoutte Battle: China and the West begins on BBC Radio 4 at 13:45 on Monday 13 Would possibly, and may be to be had on BBC Sounds