new biopic only bolsters the Amy Winehouse ‘trainwreck’ narrative carved out by noughties tabloid media

When Amy Winehouse died on the age of 27 in 2011, many felt the world had been robbed of 1 its biggest stars who had barely proven us the extent of her expertise. The brand new biopic Again to Black – directed by Sam Taylor-Johnson and named after Winehouse’s seminal second album – makes an attempt to make sense of her tumultuous life and musical output.

The movie follows Winehouse – performed by Marisa Abela – from the early days of her profession in early-2000s London, by way of to international stardom. Within the course of, it reveals the methods wherein feminine celebrities are objectified in up to date media and movie star tradition, even after their loss of life.

On the peak of Winehouse’s fame, gossip tabloids nonetheless dominated the media. They created what grew to become generally known as “trainwreck celebrities” – predominantly feminine stars who have been portrayed as publicly promiscuous and often intoxicated. Essentially the most well-known from this era embrace Britney Spears, Lindsay Lohan, Paris Hilton and Lily Allen. These feminine celebrities have been commonly shamed within the tabloid and gossip press on each side of the Atlantic.

Winehouse shot to fame along with her first album, Frank, in 2003, and was rapidly thought of one in all these “trainwrecks” for being outspoken, performing intoxicated, and stumbling out of north London bars along with her on-off lover and future husband, Blake Fielder-Civil.

All through her life, Winehouse tried to withstand this type of management and commodification. She was seen combating with paparazzi and resisting rehab when her document firm tried to get her assist (she even wrote a music about it).

Abela’s capability to mimic Winehouse’s voice and mannerisms is usually spectacular. Nonetheless, whereas within the early levels Again to Black tries to counteract Winehouse’s tabloid picture, it in the end fails to shift this broadly accepted narrative surrounding her chaotic life-style.

Amy’s distinct model

The start of the movie centres on Winehouse’s songwriting expertise and musical efficiency, which is swiftly adopted by the supply of a document contract.

Abela’s Winehouse doesn’t tire of reminding her household and the viewer that she’s not on this for the celebrity or cash. Certainly, the movie each begins and ends along with her telling us that each one she desires is to make music that helps individuals overlook their troubles, and solely desires to be remembered for being a singer and for being herself.

Winehouse’s distinctive private model is central to the visible storytelling of the movie. The singer grew to become recognized for her trademark beehive and eyeliner, in addition to a signature Fred Perry polo and thin denims mixture. She was additionally recognized for carrying pink satin ballet flats, which gained notoriety in paparazzi images that confirmed them bloodied within the public aftermath of a battle along with her husband in August 2007.

The movie makes use of Winehouse’s distinctive model to speak modifications in her well being. As a substitute of exhibiting the unglamorous and infrequently visually disturbing realities of bulimia and drug abuse, the progressively extra torn garments and baggy hair come to indicate Winehouse’s bodily and psychological decline.

Many of those model moments used within the movie weren’t impressed by seems she wore in her performances, however as an alternative have been captured by way of paparazzi footage. Whereas using these visuals amid the dramatised scenes function a reminder of the relentless media chase Winehouse needed to endure, the movie in the end reinforces this sense of media exploitation.

Slightly than providing a posh visible portrayal that goes past the “trainwreck” photos the viewer could also be conversant in, Again to Black nearly banks on how recognisable they’re. It depends on the tabloid media’s damaging visible narrative as an alternative of venturing to create its personal.

Sufferer narratives

As a biopic, the movie makes an attempt to reclaim Winehouse from the victimhood typically ascribed to her. Nonetheless, the story it tells reduces Winehouse’s complicated character and her life to a sequence of episodes of struggling.

Take a scene set within the wake of her beloved grandmother’s sickness and loss of life. Winehouse’s husband is offered because the villain who exploits her trauma as a second of weak spot, to introduce her to the identical onerous medication she rejected early on within the movie. This units Again to Black’s story on a well-recognized trajectory.

Within the movie, her bulimia occurs within the background, with scenes briefly exhibiting Winehouse in entrance of the bathroom. The one considerably specific dialogue of it seems when her flatmate complains concerning the flushing noises that wake her up.

These temporary moments function markers of unhappiness, however supply no exploration of the place this unhappiness could come from. They eschew the complexity of Winehouse and her psychological well being, and don’t supply greater than the shallow damaged artist formed by tragedy and the love of a nasty man – a story we already know.

When Again to Black does search for causes of unhappiness, it settles on odd territory. At one level, it appears to recommend that her struggling stems from an unfulfilled need to be a mom – a take that has garnered deserved criticism.

In the end, Again to Black is unable to seize what made Winehouse so particular: the grain of her voice, and her capability to craft tales of feminine expertise that reject simplistic narratives of struggling.

Searching for one thing good? Reduce by way of the noise with a fastidiously curated choice of the most recent releases, dwell occasions and exhibitions, straight to your inbox each fortnight, on Fridays. Enroll right here.